what car insurance has the best rates

What Car Insurance Has The Best Rates

Car insurance is a legal requirement for all drivers, but rates can vary widely between companies. Choosing the right policy with the best rate takes research and comparison shopping. This article will provide tips on how to find the most affordable car insurance.

How Insurance Companies Determine Rates

Insurance companies use various factors to calculate premiums including:

  • Your driving record – tickets, accidents, claims
  • Type of vehicle – make, model, age
  • Your location
  • Your age and gender
  • Your credit score
  • Your coverage limits and deductibles

American Family: Best for Low Level of Complaints

American Family earns high marks for customer satisfaction and maintaining low complaint levels. They resolve issues efficiently, limiting grievances. Their personalized service and responsiveness result in fewer dissatisfied customers compared to competitors. If minimizing headaches is your priority, American Family is a great choice.

NameRatingPrice
American Family5/5$2,176
American Family: Best for Low Level of Complaints

This table provides a concise overview of American Family’s strong rating for its low level of complaints while noting that the price can vary based on the specific coverage options chosen by the customer.

Pros:

  • Strong Customer Satisfaction
  • Low Level of Complaints
  • Customizable Coverage
  • Multiple Coverage Options

Cons:

  • Limited Availability in Some States
  • Not Always the Cheapest Option
  • Regional Variations in Service
  • Limited Digital Tools
American Family: Best For Low Level Of Complaints
American Family: Best for Low Level of Complaints

Auto-Owners: Best Cost for Drivers Who Have Caused an Accident

Drivers with recent at-fault accidents pay much higher rates. Auto-Owners reduces the rate spike through accident forgiveness. Rates won’t skyrocket with just one covered incident. The premium increase is smaller than most insurers, easing the pain for drivers who made a mistake.

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Auto-Owners:$1,6285/5B+
Auto-Owners: Best Cost for Drivers Who Have Caused an Accident

This table provides a concise overview of Auto-Owners’ competitive pricing for drivers with accident histories, its high rating, and its excellent collision repair grade, highlighting its strengths in these areas.

Pros:

  • Competitive Rates for Accident History
  • Excellent Customer Satisfaction
  • Wide Coverage Options
  • Local Agents for Personalized Service

Cons:

  • Limited Availability in Some States
  • Regional Rate Variations
  • Less Advanced Digital Tools
  • Fewer Discount Options
Auto-Owners: Best Cost For Drivers Who Have Caused An Accident
Auto-Owners

Nationwide: Good for Usage-based or Mileage-based Insurance

Nationwide’s SmartMiles program uses a small device to track driving data like mileage and habits. Safer drivers earn bigger discounts, with average annual savings up to $130. Infrequent drivers save the most, making it ideal for those needing a low-mileage plan. The program is easy to use and effective at reducing premiums.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for Nationwide, emphasizing its suitability for usage-based or mileage-based insurance:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Nationwide$2,0415/5C
Nationwide: Good for Usage-based or Mileage-based Insurance

This table provides a concise overview of Nationwide’s pricing, customer rating, and its collision repair grade, highlighting its suitability for usage-based or mileage-based insurance.

Pros:

  • Usage-Based/Mileage-Based Options
  • Good Customer Satisfaction
  • Wide Coverage Choices
  • Nationwide Agent Network

Cons:

  • Limited Availability in Some States
  • Not Always the Lowest Rates
  • Less Advanced Digital Tools
  • Regional Variations in Service
Carnexus
Nationwide

USAA: Best for Military Members & Veterans

Exclusively serving the military community, USAA consistently delivers top-notch service, great rates, and high satisfaction. Their financial strength indicates solid ability to pay claims. Membership eligibility makes USAA ideal for active and former military seeking the best overall value.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for USAA, emphasizing its suitability for military members and veterans:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
USAA$1,4125/5C
USAA: Best for Military Members & Veterans

This table provides a concise overview of USAA’s pricing, customer rating, and its excellent collision repair grade, highlighting its strength in serving military members and veterans.

Pros:

  • Tailored for Military Members
  • Exceptional Customer Service
  • Extensive Discount Options
  • Strong Community Support

Cons:

  • Limited to Military-Affiliated Individuals
  • Few Physical Locations
  • Not Available to the General Public
  • Rates May Not Always Be the Cheapest
Usaa
USAA

Geico: Best Overall Car Insurance Rates

Known for highly competitive pricing, Geico lives up to its advertising promises. Drivers in many situations can find some of the cheapest quotes from Geico. Combine this with good financial standing and easy online access, and Geico emerges as a prime choice for the budget-conscious.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for Geico, emphasizing its strength in offering the best overall car insurance rates:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Geico$1,7164.5/5C-
Geico: Best Overall Car Insurance Rates

This table provides a concise overview of Geico’s pricing, customer rating, and its “Very Good” collision repair grade, highlighting its strength in offering competitive car insurance rates.

Pros:

  • Competitive Rates
  • User-Friendly Digital Tools
  • Wide Coverage Options

Cons:

  • Mixed Customer Service Reviews
  • Limited Discount Variety
  • Primarily Online-Based
Geico
Geico

Travelers: Best Price for Gap Insurance

Gap insurance covers the difference between your car’s depreciated value and any remaining loan balance if it gets totaled. Travelers offers gap coverage at just $25 per year, much less than dealerships charge. This protection is vital for newer cars drivers still owe money on.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for Travelers, highlighting its strength as the best price for gap insurance:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Travelers$1,8524.5/5C+
Travelers: Best Price for Gap Insurance

This table provides a concise overview of Travelers’ pricing, customer rating, and its “Good” collision repair grade, emphasizing its suitability for gap insurance at a competitive price.

Pros:

  • Competitive Gap Insurance Pricing
  • Wide Range of Coverage Options
  • Good Customer Satisfaction

Cons:

  • Some Regional Availability Limitations
  • Potential for Lower Customer Satisfaction in Comparison
  • Limited Digital Tools
Travelers:
Travelers:

Westfield: Best Family Discounts

Families can take advantage of Westfield’s extensive discounts like multi-car, safe driver, good student, defensive driving, and more. Combine policies to maximize savings. Discounts offset rate hikes from teen drivers. Westfield makes bundling affordable coverage for the entire household easy.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for Westfield, highlighting its strength in offering the best family discounts:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Westfield$1,7594.5/5B
Westfield: Best Family Discounts

This table provides a concise overview of Westfield’s pricing, customer rating, and its “Very Good” collision repair grade, emphasizing its suitability for families seeking insurance with attractive discounts.

Pros:

  • Best Family Discounts
  • Strong Financial Stability

Cons:

  • Limited Availability in Some States
  • Fewer Coverage Options
  • Mixed Customer Service Reviews
Westfield
Westfield

Erie: Best Grade from Collision Repair Professionals

Erie receives top marks for claims service quality from industry surveys of auto repair businesses. This indicates fair appraisals, quick payments, and efficiency minimizing downtime. Erie makes the claims process smooth, getting your car fixed and back on the road rapidly after an accident.

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Erie$2,1444.0/5B+
Erie: Best Grade from Collision Repair Professionals

This table provides a concise overview of Erie’s pricing, customer rating, and its “Excellent” collision repair grade, highlighting its strength in receiving high marks from collision repair professionals.

Pros:

  • Excellent Ratings from Collision Repair Professionals
  • Competitive Rates

Cons:

  • Limited Availability in Some States
  • Fewer Digital Tools and Features
  • Mixed Customer Service Reviews
Erie
Erie

Progressive: Best Price for Drivers With a DUI

Having a DUI significantly increases car insurance rates. Progressive discounts DUI policies greater than other large insurers. The rate hike is smaller in the first years after a DUI compared to competitors. For drivers needing coverage after a DUI, Progressive offers the most affordable option.

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
Progressive$2,1574.0/5C
Progressive: Best Price for Drivers With a DUI

This table provides a concise overview of Progressive’s pricing, customer rating, and its “Good” collision repair grade, highlighting its suitability for drivers with a DUI at a competitive price.

Pros:

  • Competitive Rates for Drivers with a DUI
  • User-Friendly Online Tools
  • Wide Range of Coverage Options

Cons:

  • Mixed Customer Service Reviews
  • Rates May Not Be the Lowest for Clean Record Drivers
  • Primarily Online-Based
Progressive
Progressive

State Farm: Best Renewal Discount

State Farm rewards loyal customers starting in the 2nd policy year with increasing renewal discounts. After four years, savings reach 15% of premiums and keep rising every renewal up to 30%. Long term customers get the full discount in the 10th year. This loyalty incentive keeps State Farm highly competitive.

Certainly, here’s a table with columns for “Name,” “Price,” “Rating,” and “Collision Repair Grade” for State Farm, emphasizing its strength in offering the best renewal discount:

NamePriceRatingCollision Repair Grade
State Farm$1,9594.0/5C-
State Farm: Best Renewal Discount

This table provides a concise overview of State Farm’s pricing, customer rating, and its “Very Good” collision repair grade, highlighting its strength in providing attractive renewal discounts.

Pros:

  • Best Renewal Discounts
  • Extensive Network of Local Agents
  • Coverage Customization

Cons:

  • Rates May Not Always Be the Lowest
  • Mixed Customer Service Reviews
  • Limited Digital Tools
  • Availability Can Vary by Location
State Farm
State Farm

How Can I Find the Best Price on Car Insurance?

Finding affordable car insurance requires getting quotes from multiple companies and comparing rates. Prices can vary widely for the same coverage. Follow these steps:

Get quotes from at least 5 insurers including large national and regional companies. Use online comparison sites for quick rate estimates. Compare the exact same coverage amounts, limits and deductibles on each quote.

Provide the same accurate information to every insurer including driving record, vehicle details and mileage. Consider bundling policies like auto and homeowners insurance with insurers that offer multi-policy discounts.

Ask about all available discounts like safe driver, low mileage, good student, anti-theft devices, etc. Adjust deductibles and liability limits to balance premium costs with out-of-pocket risk.

Check insurer ratings for financial strength and customer satisfaction scores. Narrow down the options to the most affordable quotes with highest rated companies.

What Is Car Insurance?

Car insurance is a contract between you and an insurer that provides financial protection against losses from an accident or theft. In exchange for premium payments, the insurer agrees to pay covered losses minus any deductibles.

Coverage pays for car repairs, medical bills for injuries, and liability claims against you up to policy limits. Certain coverages are mandatory in most states.

Types of Car Insurance

  • Liability – Covers injury and damage you cause to others. Required in all states.
  • Comprehensive – Covers damage to your car from weather, theft, fire or vandalism.
  • Collision – Covers your car’s damage from accidents with other vehicles or objects.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist – Protects you if injured by a driver with no or low insurance.
  • Personal Injury Protection – Pays medical expenses for you and passengers, regardless of fault.
  • Gap Insurance – Covers the gap between car value and loan amount if totaled.

What Types of Car Insurance Are Required?

Liability insurance is mandatory in every state but requirements vary. Most states require:

  • Bodily Injury Liability – Covers injury costs to others when you’re at fault.
  • Property Damage Liability – Pays for damage you cause to others’ property.
  • Minimum limits range from $10,000 to $100,000 in coverage depending on the state.

Methodology

This guide was researched and written by financial experts and seasoned auto insurance industry professionals to provide readers with tips on finding affordable car insurance rates.

FAQs

Who gives the lowest car insurance rates?

Geico and Progressive consistently offer some of the lowest average car insurance rates across most demographics. They invest heavily in technology and automation to minimize overhead costs, passing the savings to consumers through reduced premiums. However, make sure to compare quotes from them along with other top insurers and regional players. Rates can vary significantly based on your specific circumstances, location, driving history and other factors. The cheapest company ultimately depends on an individual’s personal profile.

What is the #1 auto insurance in the US?

State Farm holds the largest market share of any auto insurer in the U.S. at over 18% of the total industry. They insure over 80 million vehicles across the country. State Farm’s popularity comes from providing quality service through local agent offices, competitive pricing with many discounts, and strong financial ratings. High customer retention contributes to their leading position in the auto insurance sector.

Who is cheaper Geico or Progressive?

Geico and Progressive have very similar average premiums across most driver categories. Geico rates tend to be marginally lower for drivers with excellent credit and clean records, while Progressive offers better pricing for high risk drivers. Ultimately the cheaper option depends on your specific details. You need to get quotes from both to determine the lower rate for your situation.

What is the best car insurance at the moment?

For the average driver, Geico, Progressive and State Farm consistently provide some of the most affordable rates along with high financial strength ratings and good customer service satisfaction. USAA is the best overall insurer based on service quality and member discounts, but is only available to military affiliated customers. Carefully compare quotes from these leading national providers to find the cheapest premium tailored to your profile.

Conclusion

Finding the cheapest car insurance requires getting multiple quotes, comparing rates carefully, adjusting deductibles and coverage, and maximizing available discounts. While premiums vary based on your personal profile,

selecting a highly rated national insurer that offers extensive discounts provides the best opportunity to minimize the cost of quality coverage.

Use online quotes and comparison tools to efficiently shop top providers. With an organized search, drivers can obtain ideal insurance protection at the lowest practical rates.

Related posts

Leave a Comment